A Song to Drown Rivers: Deluxe Edition

Caleb B

Interesting take of an older legend

"A Song to Drown Rivers is a captivating retelling of the legend of Xishi, one of Ancient China's famed Four Beauties, reimagined with modern emotional depth and narrative clarity. Blending historical inspiration with espionage, romance, and political intrigue, Ann Liang breathes new life into a well-known tale, offering readers a heroine who is both sharp and vulnerable. The story follows Xishi, whose beauty becomes her most powerful weapon as she is recruited to infiltrate the Wu court and help bring about its downfall. Her journey—from village girl to consort to spy—is emotionally charged and richly detailed, highlighting the heavy burden of being both a symbol and a pawn. Liang's portrayal of the bond between Xishi and Fanli simmers with intensity, though their romance develops a little too quickly to feel fully earned. While their chemistry is strong, the immediacy of their connection might leave some readers wishing for more gradual development. Similarly, the complexity of Xishi's role as a consort—especially to a ruler who shows her care—feels underexplored. The idea that she could remain emotionally detached over two years, despite the ruler’s increasing affection, stretches believability at times, especially in light of his tragic ending. Still, the novel’s greatest strength lies in its emotional stakes and moral ambiguity. The final act, where betrayal looms and tragedy strikes, delivers a predictable but poignant twist. Fanli’s attempt to preserve Xishi’s legacy—ensuring she is remembered as a hero rather than a traitor—is both heartbreaking and uplifting. Overall, A Song to Drown Rivers is a moving story of sacrifice, power, and agency. While some aspects of the romance and emotional realism falter slightly, Liang’s lyrical prose and strong thematic focus make this a memorable and worthwhile read for fans of historical fiction and feminist retellings. ["

Show more

August 18, 2025 Verified Purchase

Chelle Saints

SPOILERS!!

"A Song to Drown Rivers intrigued me with its premise and promise of a strong female main character who is asked to use her beauty to bring down a king, but what will really make me remember this story for a long time is the amount of emotions Ann Liang has evoked from me through her writing. The way Ann Liang writes character development is absolutely beautiful!!! The emotions Xishi goes through in accordance with the decisions she makes and the reactions to the actions of the other characters around her is so genuine and thoughtful! One thing I did not expect to do while reading this book was SOB. I think of this story and it makes me want to cry all over again just knowing the characters and their endings. The character development of Xishi's emotions toward Fuchai throughout the story was so believable to read! Having her spend so much time with the enemy then getting to know him and understand him and having that conflict with her original feelings towards him (while her still having love for Fanli) felt so real and right! Having Xishi cry over Fuchai's body after delivering the killing blow was so cruel but beautiful in her character development and I'm glad there was a scene like that to really solidify growth of Xishi's character. Liang really wounded my heart with the scene where Fanli was burying Xishi and he told the boy to spread the word that she was still alive and travelling the world because it was the ending she deserved for her hero's tale. And I absolutely understand why the king had Xishi killed in the end (war and kings and such mindset) and Fanli's response to it just devastated me! So cruel, tragic, and beautiful! I know there is happiness in the end of the story, but just the way Liang wrote the scenes where Fanli is in ruins just really evoked strong emotions from me. It was like I wanted a happy ending because it was such a tense situation that was successfully pulled off, but at the same time somewhere in the back of my mind I knew an immediate happy ending was too easy for an epic story like this. The story of Xishi is one of bravery, of selflessness, and a cruel but beautiful mix of evoked emotions! ["

Show more

April 10, 2025 Verified Purchase

S.J

Suspend disbelief if you want to enjoy the story

"While there were some relatively well written aspects of the book, there were issues as well. Multiple hurried plot points, lack of historical accuracy and loopholes took me out of the story far too many times. In one of several similar instances, we are expected to believe a several month long trip of important folks with a big retinue is organized overnight, in order to move the story along. This also included a particular major character's downfall - the hurried plot meant it felt unbelievable when it happened.Some characters also suddenly become super loyal / dying / switching allegiance with no consequences or a hurried explanation, to the point where it does not make sense. For historical readers, it felt off to have some of the ancient chinese female characters speak and behave in such a direct, westernized and modern way. I get the author probably did not want to get bogged down by detail and wanted to move the story along. However it came across as writing them that way out of convenience rather than sticking to what is more believable. The adaptation of Xishi into a story is an interesting premise. But this book did not deliver a gripping historical read. ["

Show more

December 2, 2024 Verified Purchase

Trent

loved it !!!!

"Gosh it was amazing!!!!! I fell in love with her world, the characters, everything. It was like poetry. There was not a single page I didn’t look forward too. Author did an amazing job of conveying both sides of war. I really felt like she understood the humanity of both sides, which was beautifully done. I genuinely ache for all the people in that book. -Content rating - No swearing Totally clean Tragic/poetic ending Drinking 2/5 Spoilers ——- I want to know if anyone else wanted her to end up with the wu king!!!!!!!! I cried and cried and cried. I’m so sad actually he didn’t deserve that. Especially in the light that the author created him. After reading the book, I had to go search up the legend on my own to understand some more context. the legend paints the wu king as purely evil negligent, and wasteful which makes sense but but knowing the king that we had, I can’t help but mourn for him. Given the chance and the proper knowledge, I really think the Wu king and our main character could have saved the people and stopped the war. The way the story developed it really sounds like somebody was planning the war between them, which I guess is true. I was really rooting for them to end the war and become friendly kingdoms. But the author did such a good job of conveying, the emotion of greed between men and power. I think the author did an amazing job and I wouldn’t change a single thing. ["

Show more

December 27, 2024 Verified Purchase

Adrianna Marie

Amazing story, beautiful writing

"Thank you so much, NetGalley, for this book. I am so grateful to have had the chance to read this book. Oh my goodness, this quickly became one of my top reads of the year. The only reason I gave it 4 stars inches of 5 is because I wish the ending had been somewhat happier, and I felt like it was a little bit fast-paced and wish we had more of the actual training and time together before she went to the King. This book was so beautifully written, I couldn’t find a single fault with it. Usually I find something little that bugs me about the writing - choppy sentences, weird descriptions, using certain words to describe things - but this book was absolute perfection. I quickly became hooked on the story and found that I couldn’t put it down. I typically fall asleep before 10 pm because I’m up very early in the morning, but this book kept me reading until almost midnight every night. I quite literally fell asleep with the book in my hands because I couldn’t put it down. The story was so wonderful, and I loved the characters. I wish we had gotten more of the training, and more time with certain characters. I do feel like it was a little bit fast paced because there were some time jumps. But I truly loved every bit of this book, and ended up buying a physical copy so I can read it over and over, and make my sisters read it too, I definitely want to read more by this author. Her writing and storytelling captured me so completely, it brought me out of a weeks-long book slump. ["

Show more

October 10, 2024 Verified Purchase